our first manufacturing run made zero tubes (and an $8,000 repair bill)

Mujtaba Poda

By Mujtaba Waseem

mujtaba is the founder of poda — the world's first matcha paste in a squeeze tube. after 500 days of experiments, he figured out how to cold-concentrate matcha without the bitterness. based in los angeles.

poda team in hairnets at a filling machine during poda's first manufacturing run

our first manufacturing run made zero tubes.

not a few bad tubes. not a small batch we had to throw away. zero.

it also cancelled the production, almost broke a $50,000 machine, and left us with an $8,000 repair bill.

and somehow, that was the day poda felt real.

before the factory

poda founder making a small batch of matcha paste in a home kitchen

before any of this, poda lived in our kitchen and lab.

we made tiny batches. we mixed everything ourselves. measuring, stirring, squeezing, tasting, doing it again. it worked at the size of a kitchen counter, which is a very forgiving size.

at some point, a kitchen counter stops being a business. so i asked my manufacturer a question that, in hindsight, should have come with a warning label:

can i do a trial run at your facility?

he said yes.

the day of the trial run

poda matcha paste trial run on an industrial filling machine

i showed up with all of our poda ingredients. hairnet on. heart pounding.

if you have never stood next to an industrial filling machine holding a bucket of something you invented, it is a very specific feeling. half excitement, half "i hope nobody notices i have no idea what i am doing."

we loaded it up.

and the machine started choking.

the outflow slowed down. then it slowed down more. then everyone in the room started looking at each other in the way people look at each other right before something expensive happens.

we had to stop everything.

matcha paste being loaded into a clogged filling machine

the peanut problem

industrial machine previously used to press peanuts

here is what we did not know going in: the machines we were using had previously been used to press peanuts.

peanut butter and matcha paste sound similar. they are both pastes. they both come out of machines. they are not the same thing.

cold-pressed matcha turned out to be a completely different beast.

what we expected

what actually happened

a machine built for paste would handle our paste

a machine built for peanuts did not love matcha

a first run of real tubes

zero tubes

a production schedule

a cancelled production

a small learning moment

an $8,000 repair bill

a calm, professional day

almost breaking a $50,000 machine

if you want the longer explanation of why matcha paste behaves the way it does, read what is matcha paste. the short version: it is not peanut butter. we learned this the expensive way.

holy sh*t, we're actually doing this

pot of stuck cold-pressed matcha paste after a failed manufacturing run

so the first trial run ended with zero product, a cancelled production and an $8,000 repair bill.

and i just stood there next to a pot of very green, very stuck matcha, thinking:

holy sh*t. we're actually doing this.

which sounds like the wrong reaction. it probably was. but up until that day, poda was an idea, a kitchen experiment, a kickstarter page and a lot of conversations. that was the first day it had real problems. real machines. real money. real consequences.

nothing feels more real than a repair bill.

the other thing we got wrong: the tube

the machine was not our only mistake. the tube was too.

the very first prototype i ordered from a factory was forest green and held 100 grams.

why 100 grams? because we thought a serving would be 5 grams. 20 servings, 5 grams each, 100 grams. clean math.

then we actually started developing the product, and realized one serving was closer to 10 grams.

which would have been fine, except i had already promised 20 servings per tube on kickstarter.

so we had two options: change the promise, or change the tube.

we doubled the tube.

the first prototype

the tube now

color

forest green

bright green

size

100g

200g (7 oz)

serving size

5g (on paper)

about 10g (in real life)

servings per tube

20

still 20, as promised

the tube got bigger instead of the promise getting smaller. honestly, that is still one of the better decisions we have made. if you want to know why it is a tube at all, read why we put matcha in a tube.

what the mess taught us

the version of the story that sounds good on a pitch deck is "we launched a matcha paste in a tube."

the real version has peanut machines, wrong math, a very patient manufacturer and a repair bill.

the mistake

what it taught us

assuming any paste machine works for matcha

cold-pressed matcha needs to be treated like its own thing

guessing the serving size before making the product

test the real thing before you promise the number

promising 20 servings too early

if you make a promise, keep it, even if the tube has to double

every tube since started with this mess.

why we are telling you this

most brands show you the clean version. the finished tube, the nice photo, the "squeeze, stir, sip."

we like the clean version too. it is on the tube.

but the tube in your kitchen exists because one very expensive day went completely wrong first. we think you should know that. it is part of what you are buying.

if you are wondering whether a matcha in a tube can actually be good, read is poda matcha legit. if you just want to make something with it, start with how to make a matcha latte at home in 60 seconds. it takes less time than the machine took to choke.

→ try poda matcha paste

— mujtaba, founder