mushroom coffee vs matcha: what you're actually paying for

Mujtaba Poda

By Mujtaba Waseem

mujtaba is the founder of poda — the world's first matcha paste in a squeeze tube. after 500 days of experiments, he figured out how to cold-concentrate matcha without the bitterness. based in los angeles.

mushroom coffee vs matcha: what you're actually paying for

last month i stood in a grocery store coffee aisle and counted the mushroom coffees.

i stopped counting. there were a lot.

lion's mane. chaga. cordyceps. reishi. "adaptogenic blends." boxes promising focus, calm and an immune system that does push-ups.

and i get it. i really do. but standing there, one question kept bugging me: what are these actually fixing?

what mushroom coffee is trying to solve

strip away the packaging and every mushroom coffee is chasing the same feeling.

energy that feels smooth. focus without the jitters. and no 3pm crash where you stare at your laptop like it owes you money.

that is a completely fair thing to want. regular coffee can be a lot. so brands started adding things to it: mushrooms, adaptogens, collagen, whatever is trending that quarter.

here's the thing, though. there's a drink that's been doing the "smooth energy" job for a very long time, with one ingredient.

what's actually in mushroom coffee

most mushroom coffee is regular ground or instant coffee mixed with powdered mushroom extract. the most common ones are lion's mane and chaga, sometimes with cordyceps, reishi or turkey tail.

the mushrooms themselves have no caffeine. they replace some of the coffee in the blend, which is why most mushroom coffees land at roughly half the caffeine of a normal cup. that "smoother" feeling? a big part of it is simply less caffeine.

as for the mushrooms doing the heavy lifting: the research is early. most of it is in cells and animals, and the human trials that exist are small. healthline's review puts it plainly: human studies on mushroom coffee's health effects are lacking.

that doesn't mean mushroom coffee is bad. it means the box is doing a lot of talking.

what's in matcha

matcha is one thing: green tea leaves, shade-grown and stone-ground. no blend needed.

and it naturally comes with the two things mushroom coffee is trying to recreate.

what you want

how mushroom coffee does it

how matcha does it

energy

coffee, usually less of it (about half a normal cup)

its own caffeine. one serving of poda has 65mg

a calmer, steadier feel

added mushroom extracts, still being studied

l-theanine, an amino acid found naturally in tea leaves

ingredient list

coffee + one or more mushroom extracts, sometimes more

tea leaves

taste

coffee, slightly earthier

creamy and rich, especially with milk

caffeine and l-theanine together is the reason a lot of people say matcha energy feels calmer and steadier than coffee. everyone's different, so if you're sensitive to caffeine, start small.

65mg caffeine printed on a poda matcha paste tube

for the full caffeine breakdown, read how much caffeine is in matcha. for what's actually inside the leaf, read what is matcha made of.

the price per cup

this is the part nobody puts on the front of the box.

drink

roughly per cup

popular mushroom coffee brands

about $1.05 to $1.50

poda, 1 tube (20 servings)

$1.50

poda, 4 tubes (80 servings)

about $0.99

matcha latte at a café

$6 to $8, plus the line

mushroom coffee prices are per-serving estimates from label and retail data and change often. milk not included in any of these. we checked.

so why isn't everyone just drinking matcha?

honestly? the ritual.

somewhere along the way, matcha came with a whisk, a bowl, a sifter, a water temperature and a "right way" to do it. the ritual is beautiful. it's also a lot before 8am.

so people who wanted calmer energy went looking for something easier. and the coffee aisle was happy to help.

that's the gap we built poda for. not to replace the ritual. just to give you a version for tuesday mornings when you're already late. if you want the longer story, read why we put matcha in a tube.

holding a tube of poda matcha paste

the 30-second version

step

what to do

1. squeeze

about 1 tablespoon of poda into a glass

2. stir

add a splash of warm water and stir until smooth

3. sip

pour over milk, iced or hot

no whisk. no sifting. no mushrooms. full walkthrough here: how to make a matcha latte at home in 60 seconds.

squeeze poda into a glass, stir with water, pour over milk for an iced matcha latte

should you switch from mushroom coffee to matcha?

if you…

then…

love the taste of coffee and just want less caffeine

mushroom coffee or half-caf might be all you need

want smoother energy without a long ingredient list

try matcha

tried matcha once and it tasted like a lawn

read what does matcha taste like, then try it again with milk

are coming from coffee entirely

read matcha for coffee lovers

faq

does mushroom coffee have caffeine?
usually yes. most blends are still coffee, so they typically land around half the caffeine of a regular cup. check the label, because not every brand prints it.

is matcha better than mushroom coffee?
it depends what you're after. if you want calmer energy from a single ingredient, matcha does that naturally with caffeine and l-theanine. if you love coffee's taste, mushroom coffee keeps it.

how much caffeine is in poda?
about 65mg per serving, roughly one tablespoon.

can i mix poda into coffee?
you can. we just think it tastes better with milk.

the short version

mushroom coffee is coffee working really hard to feel calmer.

matcha already is.

it just needed to be easier to make.

mujtaba, poda's founder, holding a tube of poda matcha paste in the coffee aisle

→ try poda matcha paste

— mujtaba, founder